掲示板 Forums - しつもん:げんき
Top > 日本語を勉強しましょう / Let's study Japanese! > Anything About Japanese > Grammar Library Talk Getting the posts
Top > 日本語を勉強しましょう / Let's study Japanese! > Anything About Japanese > Grammar Library Talk
How are these answers looking? I was answering questions from the Genki 1 textbook.
1.はい、日本のレストランがあります。たべものはおいしい。(Is there a Japanese restaurant in your town?)
2.はい、家に猫がいます。(Do you have a cat at home?)
3.学校にクラブがあります。(What is there at your school?)
4.はい、日本人の学生がいます。(Are there Japanese students at your school?)
5.デパートにふくとゲームがあります。(What is there at the department store?)
6.一人で勉強します。/勉強しています (Who is in the classroom?)
7.どうぶつがたくさんいます。ライオンがいます。(What animals are there at the zoo?)
8.私の家にお茶のコレクションがあります。(What do you have at home/in your house?)
9.スコットランドしゅしんです。しろがあります。(What country are you from? What is there in your country?)
6. feels like hey are looking for an います answer
3. Short a character on the end :)
1. Probably want to keep the second sentence in polite form with です.
7. Look at your first sentence - the が marker is in the wrong place (compare to second sentence in that answer). No need for を
8. Double が, wrong verb.

こんばんは!
I have made a couple of changes above ☺️ Thanks for your help.
For question 8, what word could I use? I do in fact have a tea collection at home - I keep it in my kitchen cupboard. Is there a better way of wording that to make get my point across clearly?
I use Genki to self-study at home. Does that sentence work for question 6?
私はきょうしつに勉強がいます。
ありがとうございます🙂👍
For 8 you want あります (existence for non living things) rather than います(for living things)
Sentence 5 would probably be better using や (for non exhaustive lists) rather than と (for exhaustive lists)
"私はきょうしつに勉強がいます。" is not correct.
"勉強がいます" doesn't make sense. It's a noun for a non living thing "studying" 勉強, which is also a する verb, matched up with the existence verb for living things います.
I'd suggest simplifying it, by getting rid of the studying component, and just say: "I am in the classroom." After you have that, then you could add the "alone/by myself" to that sentence to get "I am in the classroom by myself"
Ah, yes, you're right! I fixed the silly mistake :)
I haven't learnt how to use や in a list yet - how does that work?
I think the Genki writers wanted an answer like this: (does it work?)
きょうしつに先生がいます。学生もがいます。
How about these?
私は一人できょうしつを勉強しています。
私はきょうしつに一人でいます。
I'm finding the Genki book is asking questions and expecting answers that they haven't covered in the content yet, or maybe I'm overcomplicating the answers they want.
や grammar is here. It says it is in Genki 1 Chapter 11
https://www.renshuu.org/gramma...
きょうしつに先生がいます。(good) 学生もがいます。(When you have も you drop the が)
私は一人できょうしつを勉強しています。(The location where you are doing the action gets the で particle. The を particles is for objects that you are acting upon.)
私はきょうしつに一人でいます。(good, but "私はきょうしつに一人です". might sound more natural)
Ah, good to know! I'm on chapter 4 - I'll get there 💪 Renshuu will cover や in it's material too so I can start using it.
Thanks for your help - I'll go copy down my sentences again with the corrections 👍☺️ So helpful to have this forum to cover for the lack of a teacher and catch bad habits!